Showing posts with label Tom Hanks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tom Hanks. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 March 2017

Who really was the Spy on the Bridge?

I recently showed Spielbereg’s BFG to friends, and they loved Mark Rylance’s  motion and emotion characterisation of the Giant.     Most of them had not seen his previous performance in Spielberg’s Bridge of Spies.   That film told  the story of the capture by the FBI of a Soviet spy, Colonel Rudolph Abel, in the late 1950’s, and how he was later swapped for the American U2 spy-plane pilot, F. Gary Powers.   Tom Hanks played Jim Donovan, a lawyer who had worked for the prosecution at the Nurenberg Trials, now appointed to defend the spy.   Mark Rylance, in his first major film role, played the spy.     The film is ‘based on a true story’.

However, in the second part of this review (which I reprint from revbobsblog.blogspot)  I  look more closely what seems to be a truth hidden by this film and ask ‘Who really was Rudolph Abel?’  That is a question the CIA still want not to answer.
The Spielberg film is not primarily about the Soviet spy. It is about the American lawyer, Donovan, chosen to defend him at what was always going to be a ‘show trial’, but who did so with remarkable integrity and courage, knowing the public would despise him for his role.   Although Able was found guilty and sentenced to 30 years imprisonment he was spared execution.  Donovan made the argument to the presiding Judge that this Russian should be kept alive as one day he might be a useful pawn to swap if any American spy was caught by the Soviets.  This proved to be the case.   Four years later Donovan was asked by the U. S. Secretary of State, John Foster Dulles, to work with the CIA and secretly negotiate the swap of Abel for Powers.

Donovan again conducted himself with courage and integrity, demanding that a young American student, Frederick Pryor, should also be included in the swap. The Berlin Wall was being constructed and Pryor had just been arrested by the East German Stasi on the wrong side of the Wall.   The film tells us that the CIA were not at all concerned about this young man’s fate, but Donovan insisted, and the Stasi eventually agreed. So an individual American’s humanity and courage triumphed once again despite the heartlessness of Governments on both sides of the Iron Curtain.   Just as in Private Ryan Pryor was saved by the American Hero personified by Tom Hanks.    And the Soviet spy’s life was also saved.

After the initial arrest of Abel Tom Hanks is centre stage.   We see a little of Powers, who is never portrayed as a hero.     Like the other U2 ‘drivers’ he was given explicit instructions on how to destroy the top-secret spy plane if it might fall into enemy hands, and given the means to self-destruct if he was likely to fall into enemy hands himself.   He failed to do so.   We are not told how much he revealed to his interrogators, but I suspect he did not have a lot to reveal.

Tom Hanks played Donovan with his customary skill, making an otherwise ordinary man quietly heroic, in the mould of a Jimmy Stewart character in a Capra movie or, more precisely, Gregory Peck’s Atticus Finch.   Hanks has done this many times before – and so, of course, has Spielberg.   I rather like the fact that an actor who is hardly handsome, has never been described as sexy or been an action movie hero, is actually the biggest box office draw in Hollywood. They say his films have grossed 11 billion dollars.
And what about the casting of the Englishman Mark Rylance as Rudolph?

It seems that when Rylance was approached by Spielberg twenty years ago he chose the Shakespearian stage instead.   Hanks remarked at the time that Rylance ‘ has a great future.’   I wonder if he knows how great a past he has.   Rylance is a luminary on the Glove stage – and was of course the star of the BBC’s six part adaptation of Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall, but this was his first major film role.     Rylance can play ‘big’ if he wants to, as when playing Johnny ‘Rooster’ Byron in the award winning West End and Broadway hit, Jez Buttersworth’s Jerusalem.   But he can also play small, doing so little that every tiny thing inflection or facial shift catches our attention and tells us something significant.     He was perfectly cast here.

The Bridge’s script helped  Rylance’s minimalism. He says very little.   He says nothing that is unimportant.   His repeated response when asked by Donovan if he is worried is “Would it help?”   That is wonderful.   Someone knows that being a spy is like raising teenage children – in this at least, that when things look like going badly wrong it is far too late to start worrying.  You simply have to trust the work you did before, in the case of teenagers during those early years when you were bringing them up, in the case of a spy the trade-craft employed when setting up your legend and the routines and systems to protect it.   In both cases you also have to trust those who support you.   Your family or your employers.  Abel had done the best he could.     Although he had been betrayed by his deputy he would not sell out to his captors.   If this loyalty cost him his life, so be it.

The script is clear about the nature of Abel’s trial.   He was bound to be found guilty and nothing was going to stop that, including the carelessness of the FBI, who failed to get a warrant for the search that revealed his trove of spying equipment.    The judge chose to ignore this legal lapse.  This obviously has a contemporary relevance, and Spielberg is forthright is his criticism of extra-legal procedures in Camp X.

There is nothing gung ho here and there are no grandstanding acting performances.   Even Donovan’s performance when appealing the conviction in The Supreme Court is cut short (maybe a bad editing choice?).     All the actors simply get on with their jobs, from Amy Ryan as Donovan’s wife, Alan Alder as his boss, Dakin Matthews as the presiding judge, Sebastian Koch as the svelte East German official Donovan has to deal with in East Berlin – a lovely counterpoint to his role in The Lives of Others’ – and Mikhail Gorevoy as the head of the KGB in Berlin is properly oleaginous.   Scott Shepherd is the rat-faced CIA man.     Austin Stowel as Gary Powers is really a no more than a cypher, but the film is never about him.     He is a pawn in this game.   He is never the hero.   Donovan is.   Abel was also a hero however, as Donovan pointed out to the court.   A brave and true soldier in a Cold War.
Some critics have complained about the film’s length. I was surprised afterwards to learn that it is 141 minutes .   It did not feel like it.    It is a remarkable movie, and I strongly recommend it.

But who was Rudolph?   There is a truer and even more interesting story not told here.    It seems that the man caught by the FBI was not Colonel Rudolph Abel, but Colonel Willie Fisher.   A recent article by Simon Armstrong of the BBC (28/11/15) refers to Vin Arthey’s book Abel: The True Story of the Spy They Traded for Gary Powers, and David Saunders, a professor of Russian history at Newcastle University has also researched the full story of the spy’s childhood and career.

According to a book by the Soviet spy Kirill Khenkin Fisher was born on North Tyneside on the 11th July 1903.   Sanders has seen his birth certificate.   Fisher’s ethnically German parents were Russian Communist agitators, forced to flee Russia at the turn of the century.   His older brother Henry is believed to have organized running guns back to Russian for the communists, and Willie helped his father to distribute anti-German literature on North Tyneside.   After the Revolution the family returned to Russia and Fisher joined the Red Army.   He spoke English, Russian, German, French, Polish and Yiddish and was a gifted radio operator.    During the Battle of Stalingrad he played a crucial part in an important fuhlspiel, using false radio transmissions to convince the German High Command that one of their battle groups was cut off and operating behind Soviet lines and persuading them to send in Commandos reinforcements.     This was a deadly trap that cost the Germans dearly.     Arthey considers this to be the most significant event of his career.

After the war Fisher was trained in further spy-craft and rose in the ranks of the KGB.   He taught Konan Molodi  how to use codes an cyphers in radio signals.  Molodi later assumed the identity of Gordon Lonsdale and  ran the British Naval spy Harry Hougton at Portland, whose capture is recorded in ‘Spycatcher’ by MI5’s Peter  Wright.  In 1953 Fisher was sent to New York with a false identity to take over the Soviet spy network in the USA.

He was then the ‘control’ of the Rosenbergs and Krogers.   “The FBI was working hard to disrupt Soviet spy rings, but Fisher kept the show on the road” writes Arthey, “I don’t think his job was seeking out military secrets, but he was an important cog in the wheel that got information back to Russia.”  He may also have been regrouping the penetration of the nuclear research site at Los Alamos.   The arrest of the ‘Atom Spies’, the Rosenbergs, had thrown this mission into a spin.     Fisher’s chief operator at Los Alamos was Kitty Harris, another English born Communist spy previously trained by Willie.   But his deputy in New York, the Finnish Reino Hayhanen, was an incompetent drunk.   Under the threat of being sent back to Moscow (where he might have been ‘promoted’ by means of a Makarov pistol at the back of his head) Hayhanen defected and told the Americans everything he knew.   Because of the standard trade-craft practice of cut-outs and closed-cell structure Hayhanen did not even know his boss’s name,  only his general area of residence, cover occupation (painter and sign-writer) and rank (Colonel).   Eventually however that was enough and Fisher was arrested by the FBI and charged on three counts.

At this point Willie Fisher showed what a good spy he was.   He told the FBI/CIA that he was Colonel Rudolph Abel of the KGB.   Fisher and Abel had become friends many years earlier, so Fisher knew a lot about his friends biography.   The CIA knew such an officer existed, but they did not know that he had recently died in Moscow.     When the Americans announced the arrest of Colonel Abel the KGB knew that although their main man had been arrested the CIA did not know his real identity.   Willie Fisher maintained this pretense during the four years he spent in prison before he was swapped for Capt. Gary Powers, shot down over Russia in 1960.

So Fisher had cleverly signaled to his superiors that he had not revealed his true identity.   He had not betrayed his greatest secret.   The KGB bosses would decide if they believed him.   This would be a question of life or death if he was swapped, but there was nothing more he could do.   Worrying would not help.     The film leaves his fate unclear, and rather suggests that it would not be positive.   In fact, despite the fact that the Russians never totally trusted any spy who was not ethnically Russian, his loyalty was recognized.   He was reunited with his wife and daughter in Moscow.   He could never work abroad again and did not like being paraded round the new KGB recruits as a hero – what he called a ‘museum piece’ – he lived in Moscow until he died of lung cancer in his bed in 1971.

Steven Spielberg’s new movie tells of the arrest, trial and eventual release of this spy, but does not reveal this ultimate deception.     Nor do Spielberg and the script writers make it clear that Fisher was in jail for over four years before the swap.

All this must have been known by the film makers, as attested by the way Mark Rylance speaks his lines with a British accent.  Rylance used a Scottish, rather than Geordie, accent, because he found it easier to master, but “I’ve met everybody who knew him as an English speaker. “ says Dr Arthey.“They said he didn’t speak anything like [a Geordie]. The best we’ve got is that he spoke with a kind of Scots-Irish accent, which he told people was down to being brought up by a Scottish aunt in Boston. “

The film, along with official and unofficial sites refer to him as Rudolph Abel, perhaps deferring to the CIA who still don’t want to admit that they were fooled by their most important captive.  Professor Saunders says “We make a lot in this country about Kim Philby and the Cambridge Five, but those British spies didn’t have any rank in the KGB.   Abel (sic) is the only British-born ranking officer in Soviet external security services that we know of.”


So it seems that Willie Fisher was much more remarkable in life than he is in this film.    During WW2 he would have been seen by the Americans and British as a hero, fighting on behalf of our valued – indeed essential – allies the Russians against the Germans.   Stalin and his betrayal of  Marxism was not Fisher’s  fault, and I feel rather proud of him.

Monday, 4 November 2013

Have you hijacked us, Captain Phillips?


Oh, Captain Phillips, we have a problem.   And so it seems does Paul Greengrass, Director of the movie adapted from your memoir. “A Captain’s Duty: Somali Pirates, Navy SEALS, and Dangerous Days at Sea”  co-authored by Stephan Talty, concerning the Somalian Pirate attack on the ship you captained in 2009.    It seems that some of the crucial aspects of this story have been challenged by your own crew, including important aspects of you character, professional integrity and ‘heroics’.  

Let us try to separate the film and the story it is ‘based on’.  
Paul Greengrass is the British director who has brought the immediacy and fluidity of documentary film making into mainstream movies.   He electrified the Bourne series, and what he did there raised the bar for the Bond movies.   Captain Phillips  has some of the same kinetic excitement. 

Greengrass’s  United 93  used documented evidence to recreate the fate of those involved in the fourth plane on 9/11, which the passengers prevented from  reaching its target – and died doing so as it crashed into a Pennsylvanian field.     United 93 achieved the remarkable feat of portraying the hijackers and victims in morally equal terms.    The hijackers were not black-hat villains, but brave and frightened men who were willing to give their lives for their religious and political ideals.   We were left to make our judgments.

The pirates in Captain Phillips are not painted as villains either.  When first see Somalian crew they are being recruited for ‘work’ by the local overlords.   The work is storming merchant container ships and holding them to ransom.   But the huge ransoms demanded do not enrich the actual pirates,  who receive  a tiny fraction of the millions given up by the Insurance companies.
I was reminded of the dockland scenes in ‘On The Waterfront’, where the men with power, in this case the Union bosses who were virtually gangsters, hand out work to the desperate men looking for work.    One of the conditions of this work was that blind–eyes were turned on the rampant criminality. 
I
So Greengrass does what he so often does; he brings powerful political and economic realities home to us by showing their effect on ordinary people.   In this case Muse and his team, the ones chosen to go hunting in their small out-board motored skiffs.     The gang are played by non-professional actors.  Muse is played by Barkhad Abdi, who was spotted working as a chauffeur after immigrating to the USA from the  Yemen when he was 14.  
The  casting of Abdi is clever.  He looks like a man who has known starvation.   His seemingly frail body houses a powerful spirit – and it shines through his eyes, sometimes challenging, sometimes, arrogant, sometimes thoughtful.   Abdi’s performance is crucial, because we have to see this man as a human being,  equal to us in every way, save that of the economic and political situation that shape his ends.     Muse is  intelligent, and often wise.   He is clear about the moral justification for his action.  He does not want to hurt anyone, and sees no reason why anyone should get hurt.  This ransom exchange is, as he sees it, simply a tax collected by the poor from the unbelievably rich shipping lines that use his people’s waters to make themselves even richer.    Muse is also politically very naïve.   
Captain Phillips is played by Tom Hanks,  and so he is bound to be heroic.  Not in the action-man heroic mould, or course, but in that of an ordinary man reacting to extra-ordinary event with integrity and quiet courage.  Courage does not mean being unafraid.  It often means being very afraid, but not letting fear stop you from doing what must be done.   In this film Hank’s character does what has to be done with an understated heroism, and deep humanity.    Well, we are set up to believe in him.  We have seen Hanks in Philadelphia,  Apollo 13, and  Saving Private Ryan, in Castaway and of course as Woody In the Toy Story trilogy.  Hanks' Democratic politics and support for environmental and gay rights issues are well known so, even if we have seen Charlie Wilson’s War,  we know what to expect when we see Hanks in a film role.   He is the Gary Cooper of our times.      So simply casting Tom Hanks makes Richard Phillips heroic.  
And there we have the problem.  Eleven members of Phillip’s  crew are currently suing his shipping line for $50 million for the  "willful, wanton and conscious disregard for their safety" shown  by Phillips. The crew say Phillips received many warning  e-mails about the increasing threat of piracy near Somalia, but ignored them and kept them from his crew.   "The crew had begged Captain Phillips not to go so close to the Somali coast," said Deborah Waters, the crew members attorney.   They dispute the characterization of Captain Phillips as portrayed in his book and in this film.   They also dispute some events that are crucial to the film’s plot, but no spoilers here. 
So; here we have a well made, humane,  and politically challenging   film, with an exciting dénouement, outstanding acting by the two leads,  terrific direction,  camera work and score; but.   It purports to be a true account of true events, and while many of these are undoubtedly true,   serious  questions have been raised about the central character and his conduct.  This film is called Captain Phillips,  and he is the  hero.   His ordinariness and decency are skillfully and economically painted.    His sympathy for his hijackers is powerfully shown.    What a hero!
Do we try to keep this portrait separate in our minds from the questions raised about it from his actual crew?     Do we criticize Paul Greengrass for not doing enough research – or even for doing the research and ignoring what it told him? 

I encourage you to see this film, to think about it, and to question it.