Showing posts with label SF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SF. Show all posts

Sunday, 2 April 2017

The Ghost is alive and well.

Considering  Ghost In The Shell  let us start with a comparison.  In 1963 Porsche unveiled the 911 sports car.   Many believe it to be the greatest sports car ever made.     It was certainly innovative, even though it was built on the  previous Porsche 356.  The 911  performed wonderfully, winning many races and tours.   Over the years the car evolved.  In 1998 the air-cooled engine was replaced by a water-cooled unit and the body design underwent a major redesign.    Many owners of the previous models were outraged.   However,  even though a 2017 model does not share one component part with the 1963 model and would out-perform it in every test, they are both absolutely recognizable as 911s.      But  which is the better car?   Unless you are a Porsche owner or fan that might seem to be a stupid question, but I would not advise you to ask it at a Porsche owners club meeting.

In 1989 the Masamune Shirow produced the Japanese Manga comic book series The Ghost In The Shell, telling the tale of  the 21st century counter-cyberterrorism  Public Security Section 9, led by the cyber-cop Major Motoko Kasunagi.    This was like the Porsche 356, a brilliant achievement in the world of manga/anime.  In 1995 the Japanese animation studio  Production I. G. released the a feature film based on it and with the same title, directed by Mamoru Ochii.   James Cameron said it was "the first truly adult animation film to reach a level of literary and visual excellence.”

The outstanding visuals were achieved by uniting traditional cel work with CGI. For many film fans this is the 1963 Porche 911 of anime.   Like that car there have been many changes over the years,  and each iteration has its fans.   These include Mamoru’s  Ghost In The Shell 2; Innocence movie  and the TV Stand Alone Complex  series. 

Now we have a live action version of the original movie,  written by Jamie Moss, directed by Rupert Sanders and starring Scarlett Johansson.    In the 22 years since the first film was made technology has changed  even more radically than motor technology has in 50.    In the 2017 movie we see live actors moving in 3D CGI environments unimaginable in 1995.   The CGI also transforms  the actor’s bodies into enhanced or totally replaced versions.     But which is the better movie?   

I think that is a stupid question.   The 1995 movie did what it did just about as well as it could be done.   The visuals were remarkable at that time, just as those for Metropolis were in their time, and those of the 2017 movie are today.   The ability to shoot in Hong Kong’s streets and then reproduce them with huge holographic adverts floating in and  above them is as remarkable as the adverts in Blade Runner.

Blade Runner and Ghost in the Shell both  explore long standing and still contemporary issues.    What is the human ghost in the artificial shell?    The Japanese word translated here as ghost  is understood in Japan as being nearer to consciousness rather than spirit or soul.   The title also  refers to Arthur Koestler’s book Ghost in the Machine which looked at the  duality of mind and brain, and adopted the ‘scientific determinism’ stance that our mind is simply a product of our physical brain, rejecting the idea of soul.   The movie  asks what constitutes  ‘human’ identity when cybernetic physical and intellectual ‘enhancements’ are available and a cyber-brain can interface directly with both a body and the digitally connected world?    Is identity simply about memory?  Are we what we remember –or what we do? 

That last question is raised frequently in the new film and outside it as advancing life expectancy brings with it increased occurrence of memory loss by dementia.    If our consciousness could be digitally reproduced and stored would it still be human?   
And there are sexuality/gender issues here too.  

To simply glance at the gender issue we see that the cyber-cop Motoko  looks like a woman, but she cannot reproduce.   We do not know if she can even have sex.    Sharalyn Orbaugh pointed out that in the first  Ghost in the Shell movie we find “a narrative that is all about the nature of sex/gender identity and self-identity in general in a future world where sexual reproduction has given way to mechanical replication,"   raising the question of "reproductive sexuality in a posthuman subject”.   Austin Corbett noted that Motoko is "overtly feminine, and clearly non-female."   Carl Silvio has called the first Ghost in the Shell a "resistant film", due to its inversion of traditional gender roles, its "valorization of the post-gendered subject", and its de-emphasis of the sexual specificity of the material body.    All this is slightly paradoxical in a movie where Scarlett  Johansson so often naked – without ever seeing a human body.   That is also true/not true in her  remarkable performance in  Under The Skin.    

So did I enjoy the new movie?   Yes.   I am a fan of the original, and this film honours it, sticking close to the dialogue, plot and visual design.   I was glad to see it even includes  Gabriel the basset hound, Masomu’s companion in real life who  appears in most of his movies.  But the plot is now more coherent, the live action more engaging, the visualization is stunning.    I am sympathetic to (most) of the implicit values of the movie which are shared, I believe, with those of Blade Runner.  I summed them up in my original Blade Runner review as asking ‘what is life?’ and answering ‘Life is precious’.    Oshii has said “In this day and age when everything is uncertain, we should all think about what to value in life and how to coexist with others."

There is, however, something rather haunting about the original, enhanced by its amazing soundtrack,  almost a spiritual dimension  that the new film rather lacks.  

Scarlett Johansson is good at this kind of action heroics.   She also has a sly sense of humour that occasionally peeks out.   It is good to see Juliette Binoche as Dr. Oulet after the dreadful Godzilla.   “Beat’ Takeshi Kitano as Aramaki, head of Section 9. Pilou Asbaek, a newcomer to me, plays Sergeant Batou convincingly. 

So what about the ‘whitewashing’ issue of casting Johansson in the lead?    On the Roger Ebert review site Angelica Jade Bastien wrote
“No matter where you come down in the debate over this, it becomes hard to ignore when you notice how the most important characters are white or that every time Aramaki speaks Japanese the Major only replies in English. “Ghost in the Shell” makes the troubling decision to use Japanese culture, visual flourishes, and source material but decides that a Japanese actress as the lead would be a step too far.”

I wonder if she has bothered to watch the original movie.    In that the Major does not look at all Japanese.   There are many other Caucasian characters in the original, including the loyal (devoted?) Sergeant Batou, Dr. Oulet, the creator of the body and interface, and Dr. Dahlin,  a junior scientist who works for her, as well as the two garbage men.    Ochii had his original movie dubbed into English because he wanted it seen in the West, and those who criticize the  casting of Ms. Johansson  do not say how this very expensive movie would ever have been made without her heading the cast.   Do they name any world class – and world renowned – bankable Japanese actresses who could have got it ‘green lighted’?    Besides which the world of manga is filled with ‘round-eyed’ characters, male and female.    


So if you are new to the world of Ghost go and enjoy it.  And if you are a manga fan enjoy the idea that this film might encourage many people to watch more.   Including the original. 

Tuesday, 15 November 2016

Arrival is food for the mind and heart.

I was underwhelmed by Denis Villeneuve’s Prisoners (2013)  Despite impressive performances I thought it really took itself far too seriously.  Sicario (2015) impressed me much more – but again I was not sure what it’s moral pov was.  It seems that Villeneuve wasn’t sure either. He is quoted as saying that ‘Sicario  about the alienation of the cycles of violence, how at one point we are in those spirals of violence and ask ourselves, 'Is there a solution?' My movie raises the question; it doesn't give any answer. (IMDb)  But his new film Arrival engaged my mind and moved my heart.

This movie tackles the well worked theme of first alien contact, but does so in a remarkable and original way.   It avoids the lazy shortcuts taken by so many sf books and films (the Carl Sagan inspired Contact excepted)  of gifting our extra-terrestrial visitors with our language.    Way back in the 1960s’ SETI (the Search for Extra-terrestrial Intelligence and NASA commissioned John B. Lilly to find out how to communicate with an alien mind - using dolphins as his research field.    So in Arrivals our unlikely – and sensibly chosen -  lead researcher is a linguistic expert, Doctor Louise Banks (Amy Adams.)  She has a physicist as a colleague in case math’s is a basis for communication – as on the plaque of Voyager.    But it is Louise who takes the lead, trying to find a common vocabulary to discover the visitor’s intentions.

The first words of the movie can actually alert us to the fact that this movie is about time;  beginnings and endings.  Language, our language, is also about  beginnings and endings.     You may have come across text in which the order of the letters of each word are jumbled, but as long as the first and last letters are correct our minds sorts out the rest almost instantaneously.   But what if the record of a language was not about alphabetical sequences?    Asian ideograms work in a different way, presenting the whole idea in one image (I wonder if dyslexia is a problem for those who read Chinese). 

But if a picture is worth a thousand words, and even a thousand words could not in fact communicate the reality of a reasonably complex picture, how might that language work , not only in practice but in and on our minds?     Arrival follows Chomsky’s notion that language shapes our thinking even more than our thinking shapes our language.    A radically different kind of language might radically change not only our thinking but how our minds work. 

And so we come back to the concept of time.  Physicists, it seems, have no way of fitting the concept of ‘now’ into their work.  In Rudolf Carnap’s Autobiography he  recounted a conversation with Albert Einstein in which  “Einstein said that the problem of the now worried him seriously.   He explained that the experience of the now means something special for man, something essentially different from the past or the future, but that this important difference cannot and does not occur within physics.  That this experience cannot be grasped by science seemed to him a matter of painful but inevitable resignation.”  ( The Philosophy of Rudolf Carnap, Chicago; Library of Living Philosophers, 1963).

It has been suggested that the ‘flow of time’ from now to now is simply a construct of the mind.   We receive so much information via our senses that we need filters in order to focus.  We  ‘deaf out’ the many voices in a restaurant in order to hear the one person we are paying attention too.  Maybe we cannot cope with any overload of information unless it is parceled into packets of time, a series of ‘nows’.     What if they are all happening at the same time?   Could we cope?     This filtering could shape our experience of time.   But if, as Einstein believed,  the fact of now cannot and does not occur within physics  then maybe a language that imparted huge amounts of information in one instant, rather than in sequential parcels, could reshape the receiving mind, and allow time itself to be experienced differently.

Most of this lied under the surface of Arrivals, but not far below.   Ted Chiang, who wrote the source Story of Your Life, is a professional physicist, but it seems that like Carl Sagan he was a deep interest in humanity.    It has often been said that sf is never ultimately about aliens, but about ourselves.   So this story has a human being at  its heart.    And she is truly brave.  Politicians and members of the Military  are governed by fear; fear of any failure that could cost careers or lives.  But true scientists are not afraid of failure.    Every failure is a learning experience.   When the politicians and military are pulling back – or wanting to attack -  Louise is willing to go forward, to expose herself and reach out.   Later, much later, we discover that there is another  dimension to her courage – remembering that the word’s root is coeur, the heart. 

So what about the sf hardware?   There is a ship, in fact 12 identical ships arrive and hover over seemingly random points around the globe.   They are beautiful in their simplicity and seem to be hewn from raw rock rather that molded from polished metal.     The fact that they may come from another dimension is suggested by the way gravity behaves rather differently within them.    (String theory suggests the possibility of 11 other space-time dimensions – space Time dimensions).  

The aliens themselves are properly alien.   They might not challenge the radical alien-ness of those in China Mieville’s wonderful novels (his creatures are philosophically as well as physically utterly different), but they will certainly do. 
And of course their difference is shown, crucially, in their written form.

And so at last to the actors.    In Sicario Villeneuve cast Emily Blunt in the lead role.  Here he cast Amy Adams.     These are two highly versatile and gifted actors.  Consider Emily in Edge of Tomorrow (aka Live Die Repeat) and The Girl on the Train.   Consider Amy in American Hustle and Enchanted.    Here Amy underplays so well that under her undemonstrative surface we see so much.    She is the still centre of the storm,  and we understand why  Jeremy Renner’s character, the physicist Ian Donnelly, stands back to let her lead.    Michael Stuhlbarg and Forest Whitaker have rather under developed roles as the leaders of the CIA and military on site, and do their best. 

Eric Heisserer  wrote the script from Chiang’s story, and it is clean.   Rather a change from his usual horror fare.

Bradford Young’s cinematographer’s pallet is suitably subdued (He also filmed Selma and A Most Violent Year. )

Johann Johannsson wrote the score (as he did for Prisoners, Sicario and The Theory of Everything)  and it suits both the visual and emotional content.


In the end we find out that this is not your standard SF movie, it is not about a hostile alien invasion – or even the Close Encounter’s benignity.   We have been expertly misled, and the reveal carries a heavy punch to the heart.  Like a good detective story we had been given all the clues, in fact the biggest clue came right at the start.   But while we are being led along our way we are exposed to some heavy duty theory presented cleanly and patronizingly.    This is good  hard-core sf, and then more.  Much more.  

Sunday, 12 April 2015

Cheeky CHAPPiE does not cheer me


Some years ago an advertising agency was given the uneviable task of persuading people to drink Babycham again.   For years this cheap and cheerful bubbly had been a laughing stock, as fashionable as support stockings.    Some desperate genius came up with the line ‘Babycham? it’s so far out, it’s in.’     I do not know if Babycham sales improved.

If only Chappie was so far out it’s in.     If only it was bad enough to be a great bad movie.    I left the cinema in a state of aesthetic culture shock.    I sensed that a small group of other people who had left the same auditorium were also reeling, and joined them.     We were united in our view.  This is One Really Bad Movie. 

I enjoyed Neill Blomkamps first film, District 9.    It was an original passionate political parable, an attack on any kind of racism or xenophobia,  made by South Africans in Jo’burg, but making the oppressed race real off-planet aliens.    The ‘xeno’ in xenophobia means ‘ different’ and these aliens were truly different.      Blomkamp’s second movie, Elysium,  with Matt Damon and Jodie Forster onboard,  was also about oppression, and I enjoyed its first two acts.   The way the third act degenerated into SFX and violence – and a singular lack of narrative logic – could be put down to the usual effect that big bucks and crass studio oversight can have on new directors.  See Gozilla.    Or rather don’t. 

But can we blame the Columbia Studio for Blomkamp’s Chappie?    I do not think so.  This is a poor thing, but it is his own.    In fact it is based on a short, very short, spoof ad. written by Blomkamp and his wife Terri  Tatchell way back in 2004, before District 9 was made.    Once more we are in Jo’burg, and some reviewers have assumed that like District 9  this film it is about political  oppression, this time inflicted on the local population by a robot police force.    But no, those who face these super-cops are heavily armed criminals, not subjugated citizens, and they have been brought in because of the heavy casualties the human police are suffering.       Deon (Dev Patel)  is the young programmer who created the robot software,  but he has higher ambitions.    He wants to endow them with AI,  the ability to think and act not just independently, but with a real moral sense.   More, he wants them to have an aesthetic sense and be creative.       When he tries to sell this idea to his boss (the woefully wasted Sigourney Weaver)  she laughs him to scorn.      Have you forgotten that you work for a corporation making Police Robots? she asks.    But Deon carries on his work all night, telling his video blog at one stage that he has almost cracked the programming problem,  just a few more terabytes of code to write  he says,  and two hours later he has done it.   He has written those ‘few more terabytes’ in two hours?    Ah, but of course  he had a can of RedBull to help him, delivered in one of the most outrageous examples of product placement I have ever seen in the movie.  

Denied permission to install this software in a working robot Deon steals a damaged and decommissioned one.      Meanwhile a trio of ‘kooky’ crims decide that the way to defeat the robocops is to find a remote to turn them off, and kidnap Deon and his now robot.   At this point the movie has opened up some interesting themes,   and I had hopes that it could join Her and Ex Machina as an intelligent exploration of AI.    We do see Chappie, as he is soon called, learning.    He is like a baby Deon tells his kidnappers.    I have to educate him.   But this cognitive and development education theme is badly fluffed.    Already I was wondering  is this meant to be  a parody of the films it clearly quotes?  Is it a caper thriller/comedy?   Has it any depth?    I still do not know what it was meant to be.        It is not parodic enough, nor does it build on any of the films it references in any interesting ways, and it is certainly not thrilling or comedic enough.       

We have seen so many robots and AI computers before.   The Copbots way back in THX 1138,   Sonny struggling with ethical and loyalty decisions in IRobot.       The chilling android David in Prometheus,  Hal  in 2001.    We have genuinely thoughtful movies such as  AI, Her and Ex Machina.   But here even Chappie’s minimally sketched  education cannot be compared to that of Frankenstein’s Creature,  nor his charm to that of  WALL-E.     I noticed that the poster says CHAPPiE.    Was that meant ot have some significance?      

However, when this creation  turns on his maker, Deon, outraged by the discovery that when his battery dies so will ‘he’,  my hopes rose again.  Maybe we would have a discussion around the Theodicy question of how a ‘loving’ God can allow death and suffering in the world;  but no.    No light is shed here.    This is not a philosophical movie.  

The plot soon becomes random.    Things happen simply because the Director needs them to happen, with no logical drive.    At one stage our crims visit a supplier to buy high the explosive  they need for the Big Heist.    We never find out what this heist will actually involve.     But while in the supplier’s stronghold they say Oh, and we’ll take those too.   ‘Those’ are  Sony PS4.     Why do they want them?    Simply because in a later scene Chappie will need them (no doubt to match the Sony laptops used throughout).    But no matter, when we have no real narrative sense of what is happening Hans Zimmer’s  music is blatantly used to tell us what is happening in dramatic terms, and what we should be feeling.   The music is so explicit that it might stand on its own without needing the rest of the film to illustrate it.    That really could be an improvement.   

Sigourney Weaver has little to do here, save lend her iconic presence.  She has made many fine films, and she has been happy to work off Ripley in other sf films in amusing ways, especially in the wonderful Galaxy Quest and the slightly less than wonderful burt amusing  Paul.    But sometimes seeing her name on the poster can raise unfulfilled expectations.   It does here.   Hugh Jackman plays the villain, a rival engineer who wants to discredit Deon’s work in order to boost sales of his own gigantic Robocop copy.    He plays his part well, and is game enough to display a mullet as he does so.    Dev Patel is fine,  but he really isn’t asked to do to much with his bland, naïve character.  Sharlto Copley, first revealed to us in District 9 , provides the motion capture and voice of Chappie.    To see a robot moving like a three year old, a teenager and then a ‘cool gansta’ is fun, and he does it well.  The voice, however, becomes annoying after a while.     A couple of South African musicians, known as Die Aantwon, are cast as the criminals who become Chappie’s ‘mother and father’, and they also amuse, but their characters have no depth, and their development from vicious criminals to a pair of caring – even heroic - people has no foundations or emotional logic.

Blomkamp is a gifted, creative and committed film maker.   He is still learning his trade, and I am sure he has a long  career ahead of  him.   It cannot be easy to listen to older and wiser voices when you have made an impressive debut,   but I think he needs to if he is going to improve on Chappie.