Tuesday, 8 October 2013

The Life of Pi


Ang Lee 2013

Here are a few questions.
When surviving on the sea seems to be hopeless Pi offers himself to God,  as if saying   ‘your will be done’   and does so not in despair but almost in exaltation.    What does this mean to you?
Pi wants the tiger, Richard Parker, to be his friend, and on the life-boat he treats him with deep respect.  When Richard Parker leaves him forever Pi mourns.    What does that say to you about Pi?
At the end of the film Pi tells another story, the one the Japanese officials prefer.    He asks the author – and of course us - which we prefer.    What is your preference?
Some stories are true, factually.  Some stories are truthful, they carry meanings that can be trusted even if they are not factual.   We call some of these stories myths, and some we call parables.   Could the Life of Pi be a parable?  And if so what truthfulness does it convey?

If the second story is the factual truth how do you think it relates to the first story?

Do you have an inner Richard Parker?   If so, how do you feel about him?  Or her?

The author is told that Pi’s story will ‘make him believe in God’.  
What does that mean to you, having seen the film?
And here are a few thoughts – and more questions.
Ang Lee’s film ‘The Life of Pi’,  based on Yann Martel's Booker Prize-winning novel,  is first and foremost a spiritual journey, both  for its title character, and for his witness.   The witness, Raph Spall,  is the author who has sought out the older Pi , having been told that his story ‘will make him believe in God’.  
We soon discover that no one religion can contain the young Pi’s belief, as he learns to practice not only his native Hinduism, but also Christianity and Islam.  In a passage from the book, not included in the film,  Pi and his family are promenading along the Ponticherry sea front when they are greeted by the Hindu Guru, the Catholic Priest and the Muslim Imam, each of whom want to praise Pi for his faithfulness, but they find them selves in noisy conflict over which faith has Pi’s true allegiance. His father brings this rather unholy row to an end by exclaiming that ‘Pi only wants to love God!”
To love something means to put our faith in it.  I choose the word faith rather than belief because beliefs can be intellectual, propositional and dogmatic, whereas faith is more often visceral, emotional and adaptive.  
So how could Pi’s subsequent story of shipwreck and survival make us love and  ‘put our faith in God?’
At the end of the film we are presented with an alternative story, one that may sound much more likely than the tale of the boy and the tiger,  and asked ‘which do we prefer.’  Not believe, but prefer.
Do we simply accept that life is arbitrary, violent and ultimately hopeless,  as the second story suggests, with its elements of murder and cannibalism?    Or do we look for something other?
In the film The Mission Father Gabriel says  ‘if might is right then there is no room for God in our world’.   He is speaking in the light of God as mediated by Jesus, who showed us the vulnerable and sacrificial face of God, the face of love.   But at the end of the film we are confronted by the Papal Nuncio, played by Ray MacAnally, the man who has sanctioned violence, but who seems to be saying that, sadly, tragically, violence is sometimes unavoidable, and when it is truly unavoidable we must accept responsibility for it, and move on.  Never for a moment should we pretend that it is God’s preferred way, but understand that it is a consequence of our own sinfulness.   We must not consider it as normal, and must never get addicted to it.   Faith is not about fantasy, but we must come to terms with reality, and still keep on loving.   Is this what Pi’s journey is about?
 Why does Pi want the tiger, Richard Parker, to be his friend?    Could it be because he recognizes the instinctive reactions of the tiger, admires his strength, and recognizes them as part of his own self, maybe his id?     In the second story that Pi tells of his ordeal he does  indeed imitate the actions of the tiger.    He does not condemn himself for doing so, but when the ‘inner tiger’ is no longer needed for Pi’s survival he slinks back into the jungle and does not look back.   So maybe Pi recognized the necessity for the use of power, when it is needed, and only when it is needed.    Then we have to move on, and not ‘worship’ the beast.
Earlier, when Pi seems overwhelmed by the struggle to survive he offers himself to God, as if saying   ‘your will  be done’. Is he echoing Christ in the Garden of Gethsemane and on the Cross,  believing that God is love, and so God’s will may often be mysterious, but it is never malignant.  It is as if he is saying ‘I have done everything I can, now it is over to you God, and I will accept whatever that means.’
So do we prefer the story that sounds ‘too good to be true’,                                                                     or the story that sounds ‘too true to be good?'   
Can we accept both, while preferring, or putting our faith in, one?  
Are we condemned to believe that reality is dark, violent and hopeless, or can we put our faith in a Universe that, despite it’s shadows, is ultimately shaped by light and love, and choose to live in hope?

If God is real then nothing is more real than God, so which version of God/reality do we, like Pi, want to love?  And to put our faith in?  

By putting our faith in something could we actually help make it real?  

Apocalypse Now ! Redux.



Francis Ford Coppola, 1979 and 2001


“I was shot with a diamond... a diamond bullet right through my forehead”

 Everyone gets everything he wants. I wanted a mission, and for my sins, they gave me one. Brought it up to me like room service. It was a real choice mission, and when it was over, I never wanted another.
What was this mission?
Your mission is to proceed up the Nung River in a Navy patrol boat. Pick up Colonel Kurtz's path at Nu Mung Ba.   When you find the Colonel, infiltrate his team by whatever means available and terminate the Colonel's command.
Terminate the Colonel?
Terminate with extreme prejudice.  He's out there operating without any decent restraint, totally beyond the pale of any acceptable human conduct. And he is still in the field commanding troops .

Although Apocalypse Now! is set in the Vietnam War it is based on Joseph Conrad’s novel The Heart of Darkness, set in the late 19th century Congo.    

In Apocalypse Now! We see on Col. Kurtz’s desk two books, From Ritual to Romance  by Jessie Weston and  The Golden Bough  by Sir James  Frazer.   These books inspired T S Eliot’s The  Waste Land. The epigraph of that poem comes from The Heart of Darkness “Mistah Kurtz – he dead”.
In The Heart of Darkness (1902)  a young sea captain  is sent upriver to rescue Mr Kurtz, a brilliant and idealistic manager who is sick.  Marlow finds, however, that Kurtz is now depraved, and worshiped by the locals.  Human heads decorate his gate.  He has also taken a native ‘wife’.
The final words in The Heart of Darkness  are about the death of Mr. Kurtz, asking, 
Did he live his live again in every detail of desire, temptation, and surrender during that supreme moment of complete knowledge?  He cried in a whisper at some image, at some vision, - he cried out twice, a cry that was no more than a breathing – “The horror! The Horror!”
When Marlow returns to Europe he intends telling Kurtz’s ‘intended’ that Kurtz uttered her name as he died.  In the original script of Apocalypse Now!   Willard returns to the USA and tells Col. Kurtz’s wife and son that he lived and died a hero. 
The Wasteland (1922) reflected on the spiritual sterility of post WW1 Europe in the light of the Holy Grail legend and classic fertility rituals, alongside Shakespeare, Dante, The Christian Bible and Hindu Upanishads.    It is experimental  in form, often fragmentary and obscure, ‘a heap of broken images’.  and profoundly pessimistic – even if he uses the word Shanti as a refrain, which Eliot said could be translated as the peace of God which passes all understanding.   
Here are some quotes from Eliot’s poems.
We are those who have crossed
With direct eyes, to death's other Kingdom
Remember us - if at all - not as lost
Violent souls, but only
As the hollow men
The stuffed men.

Between the idea
And the reality
Between the motion
And the act
Falls the Shadow
For Thine is the Kingdom
Between the conception
And the creation/
Between the emotion
And the response
Falls the Shadow
Life is very long
 Between the desire
And the spasm
Between the potency
And the existence/
Between the essence
And the descent
Falls the Shadow.
                                    For Thine is the Kingdom.

And

This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
This is the way the world ends
Not with a bang but a whimper.

How do you think these quotes, referenced by Col.Kurtz,  might inform our understanding of the movie?

Eliot’s poem is emphatically religious, and Willard, our protagonist and narrator,  starts by telling us that  
There is no way to tell (Kurtz’s) story without telling my own. And if his story is a confessional then so is mine.   
Willard has to go on a journey into the heart of darkness, and that is an interior journey as much as exterior.    What is his confession about?
Apocalypse Now! is set in the Vietnam war, and even if it is not ultimately concerned with that war it is quite possibly the most accurate film ever made about that war.    These quotes ring true;
Shit... charging a man with murder in this place was like handing out speeding tickets in the Indy 500.
It's a way we had over here for living with ourselves. We cut 'em in half with a machine gun and give 'em a Band-Aid. It was a lie. And the more I saw them, the more I hated lies.
 We train young men to drop fire on people, but their commanders won't allow them to write "fuck" on their airplanes because it's obscene!
And at the end of the film Col. Kurtz tells Willard, 
I've seen horrors... horrors that you've seen. It's impossible for words to describe what is necessary to those who do not know what horror means. Horror... Horror has a face... and you must make a friend of horror. Horror and moral terror are your friends. If they are not, then they are enemies to be feared. They are truly enemies! I remember when I was with Special Forces... seems a thousand centuries ago. We went into a camp to inoculate some children. We left the camp after we had inoculated the children for polio, and this old man came running after us and he was crying. He couldn't see. We went back there, and they had come and hacked off every inoculated arm. There they were in a pile. A pile of little arms. And I remember... I... I... I cried, I wept like some grandmother. I wanted to tear my teeth out; I didn't know what I wanted to do! And I want to remember it. I never want to forget it... I never want to forget. And then I realized... like I was shot... like I was shot with a diamond... a diamond bullet right through my forehead. And I thought, my God... the genius of that! The genius! The will to do that! Perfect, genuine, complete, crystalline, pure. And then I realized they were stronger than we, because they could stand that these were not monsters, these were men... trained cadres. These men who fought with their hearts, who had families, who had children, who were filled with love... but they had the strength... the strength... to do that.
This speech is informed by a friend of the scriptwriter John Milius,  who had served in Vietnam and experienced, first-hand, the hacking off of the arms by Viet Cong.    When the film was released in 1979 many, maybe most,  critics described Kurtz’s final words as meaningless.   
Willard says, however, 
In a war there are many moments for compassion and tender action. There are many moments for ruthless action - what is often called ruthless - what may in many circumstances be only clarity, seeing clearly what there is to be done and doing it, directly, quickly, awake, looking at it.
This shocking moral perspective, exemplified by the hacking off of the children’s arms as an act of love, as something that had to be done to save them from a worse fate – the victory of the Americans and therefore their political system, is the diamond bullet.   Critics refused to allow it to enter their brains.   How do we react?    Are there some things so terrible that nothing, nothing at all, should deter us from doing what is necessary to avoid them?  Especially for the sake of those we love?
Seeing clearly what there is to be done and doing it, directly, quickly, awake, looking at it.

Maybe the critics could  not look at that terrible moral possibility.

Note about the ‘French sequence’ in the Redux version.   Vietnam used to be called Indo-China by the French, who colonized it.      The Vietnamese rebelled after WWII, with Chinese support, and eventually drove the French out.   The last great battle was at Dien ben Phu in 1954, a victory masterminded by the brilliant Vietnamese General Giap, the teacher turned soldier who died in September 2013.  
Despite this defeat the Americans fought in much the same way – and were also defeated.  They feared that if Vietnam ‘fell to the Communists’ there would be a ‘domino effect’ that turned the whole of South-East Asia Communist.    It would have cost them much less to have made every Vietnamese man, woman and child a dollar millionaire.  
Apocalypse Now! was extraordinarily difficult films to script, shoot and edit.    There were many variations of the script and edit.   Some think that Francis Ford Coppola could not find a way to make sense of the massive themes – and footage. 

What do you think? 

Friday, 20 September 2013

Film & Faith; my Entertaining Angels



Film and Faith is the topic, and this blog contains my thoughts and critiques of movies going back over the last 25 years.

I started publishing these as a booklet  for Youth Leaders, Group Leaders and Clergy 
when I was a Diocesan Youth Advisor in the Anglican Church back in the 1980’s. Some entries are just an aide-memoire and a line or two about applicability. There are also longer (sometimes much longer) articles, and these are often theological in their approach. I am a priest and although cinema provides an important cultural source I know that most of the time people go to see a movie but do not make the connections between its themes, concerns or images and their own faith. How many times has someone said to me ‘I have seen that film before, but I had never thought about it like this’?

Here you will find notes on recent films, details of two 'film seasons' I ran in my church, an some new ones I will be running where I live now.   And then the A – Z of over 100 films, followed by longer, articles on over 20 films including  The Great Gatsby, 


Anna Kerenina,   Zero Dark Thirty,    Another Earth,    Tree of Life,    Hero, Slumdog Millionaire,   the first Narnia film,    Beowulf,    The Dark Knight,  Doubt,    The Lives of Others,    American Beauty,    Hannah,   Toy Story 3, Inception,    The Road,    A Serious Man,    Doubt,   Pleasantville,    Taken and Wall-E.                                                                                                                                              You will also find some 'round up of the year' articles.
















You may agree or disagree with my theological stances and comments; they have no more authority than any of your own. But writing them has helped me deepen my own enjoyment of going to the movies, to understand which deep bells in my heart and soul they have chimed with - or been in profound disharmony with - and I have learnt so much from them.

Some of these article may be published under my name elsewhere, and I retain copyright, but I am happy for anyone to copy and use this material for church use, as long as the original authorship and source - and your edits - are clearly acknowledged.
I hoped you enjoy these ‘Entertaining Angels’!

Baz is the man for a great Gatsby



Criticisms of two recent adaptations of great works of literature show how some critics have an idealized view of these books, or of characters within the books, and complain when the film doesn’t translate these versions accurately to the screen.  Anna Karenina and The Great Gatsby are both works of acute social critique, each clothed in a love story. 
I have written about Anna Karenina elsewhere (see A Tract for Our Times), so here I will stay with Baz  Luhrmann’s recent film  The Great Gatsby. 

Novels create characters, both on the page and in our minds.    Some of these fictional characters even find their way into our hearts, either as heroes and heroines, or as romantic figures.     Sometimes we can become rather fond of them.   When these ‘written’ figures appear on screen we may be able to adapt the physical image we had of them to fit the films cast, but if they are then portrayed on screen as essentially shallow we may feel cheated.  Daisy Buchanan and Jay Gatsby, for instance, may be bathed in a romantic light in our hearts and minds,   but a film maker, paying close attention to the text from which they sprang, may see, and portray them in a less flattering light.   We may be tempted to dismiss this interpretation rather than go back to the novel and question it.  And if the book has already been filmed with a more sympathetic eye for its main characters that our feelings of alienation from the new film may be reinforced.     The Great Gatsby was last filmed in 1974 with Robert Redford and Mia Farrow playing the leads, and the film was very much a tragic romance, starring two of the most popular romantic leads of the time.   This impression was surely reinforced by the romantic fallacy that ‘good looking’ people are also possessed of a good character.   Carrie Mulligan’s performance in Baz Lurhrmann’s new film may not suffer to much in comparison, but Leonardo Decaprio’s  seems to have suffered in some people’s eyes by being seen as less romantic than Redford’s and his morality  more open to question.   The essential question is, of course, which characterization is truer to the book?

And it is not only our moral sense of the characters that can be challenged, but also that of the book.  For instance, Baz ’s version of Gatsby has been criticized by Mike Betha, the film critic of The Philadelphia Inquirer, because it seemed to distort the values fans of the story hold so dearly.    I wonder just what those values might be?   Betha says that the film makes us ‘intoxicated by the partying of the second act, but leaves us with a hangover in the third’.    But I woud argue that this is exactly what Fitzgerald intended.   He wanted to show us the totally over-the-top excess of the Jazz Age, and of course he did so in his own precise prose style.    No Gonzo writing for him.    You can film his narrative, but not his prose.  So, as Todd McCarthy, of the Hollywood Reporter writes, given the immoderate lifestyle of the title character, (Luhrmann’s)  approach is not exactly inappropriate, even if it is at sharp odds with the refined nature of the author's prose.  Having  shown us the partying Fitzgerald then shows us the aftermath.   Gatsby is not a feel-good movie.   The hangover is his, literally. And he wanted to share it with us.   

If the values we hold dearly  are subverted by the film, whose values are they?  Surely not those of Jay Gatsby?     We will back come to Scott Fitzgerald’s values later, but first let’s stay with the difference between novels and films.

You cannot film prose. You can film dialogue and stage directions, but not the author’s voice.   In moderation, as in Luhrmann’s’  Gatsby, description can be turned into voice-over or even written soliloquy.  But  when the author uses a narrator, as Fitzgerald used Nick Carraway, the narrator is not the author.  McCarthy writes that   narrator/observer characters like Nick, or Stingo in Sophie's Choice, are almost always uncomfortable fits onscreen, especially when they're far more bland and naive than everyone else around them but still prone to making assessments and judgments about people actually living life rather than standing to the side of it.

We should be careful not to adopt the values and judgments of a narrator.   Nick may well hero worship Jay, be dazzled by him and want to hang on to his ‘values’. but Fitzgerald does not. This is not Nick’s story.  It is a story he tells, and tells it the way he sees it, the only way he can, but he is inevitably an unreliable narrator.    Some distance is necessary for perspective.   
It also needs to be said that films that are too ‘literary’ usually do not work well.   The 1974 film of Gatsby was a failure for many reasons, but one of them is that it had too much respect for the prose.    It tried to be as ‘cool’ as Fitzgerald’s writing, but what Fitzgerald was writing about was frenetic.    Some films fail because without the author’s voice too much is lost – think of  Doctor Zhivago.   Many swooned at Omar Sharif’s middle distance gaze, but that is not what Pasternak’s book was about.   Even the relatively successful adaptation of The Name of the Rose only worked well on screen because the narrative and characters Umberto Eco had invented were gripping enough to carry the film, even if the actual philosophical and theological baggage the narrative was designed to carry had to be jettisoned.    Very often the only real wisdom in a book is found in the author’s voice, not the characters’ voices.   Sometimes the characters and plot carry us through, as in The English Patient.   The major characters may be smart and clever, but apart from the bomb disposal officer Kip,  they have very little wisdom.   The wisdom is that of Michael Ondaatje.    The books that translate most easily onto the screen are plot driven thrillers and fantasies.    But every now and again a cinematic genius with a deep literary sensibility comes along, and John Huston gives us James Joyce’s The Dead.

A film-maker can allude to the author’s prose, with a voice over, or as Luhrmann does at times, by showing us Nick’s journal-writings on screen, but once again they are Nick’s thoughts we read, not Fitzgerald’s. So we need to see past Nick and Daisy and Jay in order to get to Fitzgerald.  But that does not mean that we cannot be allowed to be as entranced, for a while, as Nick is with Jay, and Daisy and Jay are by each other.   But their real romance existed only in their pasts, and they cannot go back there.    All innocence has been lost, not only that of these two iconic characters, but that of the Jazz Age itself, madly in love with itself as it was.
A mad, hedonistic party has to be filmed as such, and who better than Fuhrman, and his co-creator and wife Caroline Martin,  to do so.    This is the Moulin Rouge transplanted to Long Island.    Luhrmann is not filming these party scenes in ways that overtly criticize them.  He is filming them the way they must have felt to Nick, and leaving us to stand back and judge them.   It is our judgments and values that matter, informed by Fitzgerald’s prose, translated by Luhrmann’s images. 
So when I saw this film I expected to be caught up in the glamour, the totally over the top indulgence, and to see Daisy as wonderful, captivating,  and utterly adorable, to fall for Jay’s charm and line, to be caught up in his passion for Daisy – the only innocent thing about him. As David Edelstein of CBS commented, for all its polish, the book has a healthy American vulgarity that the genteel 1974 film with Robert Redford and Mia Farrow didn't get.   If you want deliberate vulgarity, look to Baz Lehman.   He knows how to deliver it with style.

But I also expected to taste the eventual disillusionment, the bitter dregs, to feel the hangover, to feel betrayed even, just as so many ‘mad young things’ were betrayed by the illusions of the times.   Fitzgerald did not write to praise the Jazz Age, but to bury it.  He and Zelda were also its victims, and Gatsby shows us why any of us might also have fallen for it, given the opportunity.   

Fitzgerald told his daughter Scottie that he had chosen literature as his pulpit and The Great Gatsby is a great political sermon, because its author understood how it all this came to be, and the price that wouold have to be paid.    Gatsby is prophetic, written before the Fall, as it were.     The fortunes that fed the 1920’s hedonism were scarcely more respectable than Jay’s money, even if some of them had the patina that a couple of generations endows.  It was not ‘old money’ in European terms, but old enough.    And did riches bring nobility?    Tom Buchanan’s character  suggests otherwise.    Did the gap in wealth bring about compassion for the poorer? Myrtle finds out that this is not the case.    Everyone is deluded, except Tom, who needs no illusions. 

Let us not forget that the riches of the late 1920’s and early 30’s crashed,  and that crash triggered fascism in many parts of the world, not just Germany.    Most of the reforming social and political movements are a reaction against injustice.   The uncontrolled Free Market Capitalism of the post late 19th and early 20c century triggered European Fascism. Fitzgerald saw that coming in Italy, in the early days of Mussolini.  Fascism was the hangover after the party, and it was a violent conflict because those who lost wanted scapegoats, and blamed the people who were never invited to the party in the first place.    As he wrote in a letter to Roger Berlingham in 1925.   (Italy) is  a dead land where everything that could be said or done was done long ago – for whoever is deceived by the pseudo-activity under Mussolini is deceived by the spasmodic last jerk of a corpse. 

Scott Fitzgerald was a political writer and Gatsby is not a love story.   It describes love, obsessive, ego-centric, nostalgic love, but the love story here is simply a vehicle, as it is in Anna  Karenina, for something much more meaningful, and deeply political.   If Baz Lehman’s film leaves us with a bitter taste in our mouths it means he has done his translation well.  

The literary academic Sarah Churchwell sees The Great Gatsby as a "cautionary tale of the decadent downside of the American dream". As she writes   "there seemed little doubt about what was going to happen, America was going on the greatest, gaudiest spree in history.  By the early 1920s, Fitzgerald  could already sense that "the whole golden boom was in the air – its splendid generosities, its outrageous corruptions and the tortuous death struggle of the old America in prohibition".   By 1924, he was painting an indelible picture of that new life, setting his new novel in 1922 (just after the "general decision to be amused that began with the cocktail parties of 1921"), in order to tell of "a whole race going hedonistic, deciding on pleasure.     It was borrowed time anyhow – the whole upper tenth of a nation living with the insouciance of grand dukes and the casualness of chorus girls." Less than five years after Gatsby was published, the market would crash, and the Great Depression fell like a curtain over the festivities.” (Sarah Churchwell Careless People: Murder, Mayhem and the Invention of The Great Gatsby Virago, 2013.)

Churchwell goes on to say that ‘the jazz age may have ended, but …nearly a century later, his cautionary tale has returned to haunt us, warning again of the perils of boom and bust, holding a mirror up to our tarnished world…. The historical irony is that Gatsby is destroyed because in his world money did not make everything possible – but in our world it increasingly does. Today the illusion of Jay Gatsby would not have shattered like glass against Tom Buchanan's "hard malice". : Gatsby's money would have insulated him and guaranteed triumph – an outcome that Fitzgerald would have deplored more than anyone.’  And later ‘Gatsby is destroyed by the founding American myth: that the marketplace can be a religion, that the material can ever be ideal.’

Churchwell knows that “for the most part Fitzgerald's prose is a kind of experiment in restrained extravagance.  Just as the style is nearly paradoxical in its ability to cut both ways, so are the novel's meanings. It is a celebration of intemperance, and a condemnation of its destructiveness.’

All this is very well said, but she dislikes the film because it dares the same paradox.    Luhrmann gives us both the illusion and the gritty reality, the celebration of intemperance  and the condemnation of its destructiveness, and he has to do so in visual ways, rather than literary.  

I do not think that literary critics are always well suited to be film critics.     They often value the wrong – by which I mean inappropriate – virtues,  and therefore make false judgments.   Literary critics love prose.   But film is not prose.   Prose ‘tells’, film ‘shows’,  so the quality of the telling must be translated into the quality of the showing.    I first spotted this critical bias thirty years ago when the critics scorned Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner.

Watching The Great Gatsby I though DiCaprio’s performance was perfect, catching the manic and the obsessive and the potentially violent alongside the naïve and utterly vulnerable aspects of his character.  Daisy is so underwritten it is hard to make her sympathetic, but Carrie Mulligan did her considerable best.     Joel Edgerton as Tom Buchanan – who Fitzgerald thought the best character he has written – see below -  was very good indeed, as also were Jason Clarke and Isla Fisher as George and Myrtle.   I thought Nick was played by Toby Maguire as well as such a passive character could be, and the framing device worked for me.   The meeting of Jay and Daisy (which again Fitzgerald thought was the best chapter in the book) was tender, tentative, comic and moving.    

The direction and design were as bold and outrageous as the times they portrayed, and brought the prose to life thanks to Baz and his co-Producer, Production and Wardrobe Designer (and wife) Catherine Martin.  The use of the 3D was the among the best I have seen, deliberately obvious in the opening credits and used to spectacular effect in some scenes but subtle otherwise.    The musical choices were brave and brilliant,  ranging from Beyonce singing Amy Winehouse’s Back to Black , through Jay-Z (writing under various pseudonyms),  Florence and the Machine, Lana del Ray,  Bryan Ferry, Jack White and Bono, to Cole Porter, Fats Waller, Jelly Roll Morton, W. C. Handy and George Gershwin, all under the musical production of Jay-Z and with the original compositions and orchestrations of Craig Armstrong.  

I end with this, from Roger Ebert, the late lamented film Critic of the Chicago Times, about the book, not the film.

‘(Gatsby)  is a celebration of intemperance, and a condemnation of its destructiveness. It is about trying to recapture our fleeting joys, about the fugitive nature of delight. It is a tribute to possibility, and a dirge about disappointment. It is a book in which the glory of imagination smacks into the grimness of real life. As Fitzgerald's editor Max Perkins wrote in 1925: it is "a story that ranges from pure lyrical beauty to sheer brutal realism". The hard facts of power and economics play out against the mythological promises of fantasy and ideology. Gatsby learns the hard way that being found out is inevitable, escape from his past impossible; but Nick beats a retreat back home, escaping back into his own nostalgic past. We find ourselves surveying the waste and wreckage after the party ends, but ready to carouse some more’.

I think ’s Gatsby is among the very best – and most accurate – translations of any book to the screen, and if anyone feels let down by I recommend they go back to the text and see what F. Scott Fitzgerald was really saying – and not just how he was saying it.