Saturday, 7 December 2019

So what has 2019 brought me at the movies and on DVD?



As I live in the countryside of Western Ireland, my opportunities to go to the movies are limited, but many of you may be in a similar situation, so I hope this little blog offers you some suggestions to go by.   Those I have already reviewed in this blog are marked ‘See below.’  

I have gone for up to 6 stars to rate them.  Sometimes 5 are not enough. 
So. 

Joker ******  I cannot think of another movie that has taken me a month of reflection, and a second viewing,  before I could be sure of how I thought/felt about it.   The 6 stars say it all.  See below.

Us ******  My second 6* film this year. Brilliant script, direction and ensemble performances, plus a devastating social critique.   See below.  

Rocketman *****  If you are going to make a biopic of Elton the music and showmanship have to be top-drawer, and here they are.  Plus Taron Edgerton’s brilliant impersonation and Elton’s shattering honesty.  See below. 

Leave No Trace *****   I really admired Helen Granic’s  Winter’s Bone (2010) and here she takes similar tropes, father/daughter and living on or beyond the margins, and makes a film that is as tough as Winter’s Bone but much warmer, with another stand-out performance by a young actress, Thomasina MacEnzie, and the ever reliable Ben Foster.     See below.

Yesterday *****   A delightful fantasy, scripted by Richard Curtis and directed by Danny Boyle,  about a singer/song-writer who suddenly finds he is the only person on Earth who knows the Beatles songs.    Ed Sheehan makes a humble cameo as himself.    It doesn’t aim too high, but hits the mark fair and square. 

The Kid Who Would Be King ****  A low key British movie,  written and directed by Joe Cornish (Attack The Block and Ant Man)  about a 21st century ‘kid’ (played by Andy Serkis’s son, Louis Ashbourne Serkis)  who finds himself locked in battle with the Arthurian witch Morgana (Rebecca Ferguson) but aided by her brother Merlin (Patrick Stewart,  enjoying chewing the scenery) and having to use The Sword Excalibur to save everyone.  Simple and effective fun. 

Avengers: Endgame ****.  Well it had to come to a (sort of) end, even if we will still have Avenger movies coming out of Marvel.  But this is the end of the epic, the wrapper-up,  the answer to what happened next after Infinity War, and for me it does the trick.   It is sad at times without being sentimental and, as many have said, it balances the tragic with the comic.  Despite the huge amount of content it still has room to pause, to take a breath, to allow some of its actors space to breath in, to act.      

The Favourite ****  I felt I should have enjoyed Yorgos Lanthimos’s Lobster more than I did, and it took me a while to get into The Killing of a Sacred Deer, but The Favourite won me over straight away.   I must add that my companion that night said that she hated it.    I can understand why.    It seems to be a costume drama about Queen Anne, crowned in 1702 when her brother-in-law William of Orange, died.   Her best friend was Sarah, whose soldier husband, John Churchill, Duke of Marlborough, Anne put in charge of all her forces doing the turbulent and expensive War of the Spanish Succession (1701 - 14).   So far so conventional.  And unoffensive.   However, the relationship between Anne, Sarah and Abigail Hill, a ‘woman of the bedchamber’ who some suspected of seducing Anne moves us into a place where emotional fireworks and ‘bad language’ fly and tears flow as Sarah, (Rachel Weisz) and Abigail (Emma Stone) vie for the love and attention of Queen Anne, (Olivia Coleman),  who Coleman herself described as ‘spoiled, grieving sensitive and cruel. An actor’s dream’.    And she did get an Oscar for playing her, after all.  The cinematography by Robbie Ryan is as unsettling as the story, and the costumes (Sandy Powell) and production design are stunning.   So, not a film for those who like royalty to be portrayed with dignity, but for some of the rest of us an accomplished and moving treat. 

Toy Story 4 *****  A victory lap after the previous three Gold Medal Toy Story winners.  See below.

Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse ****   Maybe the most inventive Spider-man offering of them all.  Such fun.   See below.

Fighting with My Family ****   Stephen Merchant’s account of the true story of an English wrestling family, and their hopes to break into the uS scene.   See below. \

You Were Never Really Here****. Lynne Ramsay and Joaquin Phoenix combine in a brutal yet moving (sort of) thriller.   See below.

Destroyer****  Nicole Kidman on absolute top form, shedding all dignity as a broken down cop and in flashback her younger self.  See below.

Blinded by the Light ***  Another British film, co-written and directed by Grinder Chadha, the British born Kenyan Asian who gave us Bend it Like Beckham, Angus, Thongs and Perfect Snogging, and Bhaji On the Beach.   The film and its young, 1980’s British Asian hero,  are inspired by Bruce Springsteen’s music.    Funny, pertinent, and blessed by The Boss. 

All Is True ***  Kenneth Branagh has directed many Shakespearian plays on stage and film, but Ben Elton’s original screenplay he plays the Bard himself, retired to his home and (largely previously ignored) family in Stratford, where his wife (Judi Dench)  and daughters give him a hard time.   Ian McKellen turns up as The  Earl of Southampton, and also gives him a hard time, but this is classically a comedy, not a tragedy, so all ends well.  Charming.

First Man ***   Josh Singer wrote First Man, and previously a lot of The West Wing’s episodes, as well as The Post and Spotlight, so we know where he is coming from.    Damien  Chazelle wrote and directed Whiplash and La La Land,  so we know his ‘beat’.    Then we have Ryan Gosling as Neil Armstrong, as strong, silent and emotionally unobtainable as he can be, and Claire Foy as his wife, paying the personal price of such heroism, as so many women did.    I admired this movie more than I enjoyed it.    

The Lego Movie 2: The Second Part. ***   A subtle and philosophical examination of the human condition as it faces the existential threat of candy coloured aliens who....oh, no; it’s just hugely inventive fun with a great American and British voice cast that includes the amazing Tiffany Haddish.  Maybe it should be ****. 

The Red Sea Diving Resort *** Gideon Raff wrote the Israeli TV series  P.O.W. and the American version of it, Homeland.    He also wrote and directed this, which is  based on the true story of how Israeli Mossad agents set up the titular base as a cover to rescue imprisoned Ethiopian Beta Jews in the late 1970’s.   Chris Evans, Greg Kinnear and Ben Kingsley lent it their acting support.  This film did not get a positive critical reception, but I enjoyed it.   Sadly, the rescued Ethiopian’s  reception in Israel,  and the ongoing immigration rules that apply to other Ethiopian Jews there,  have not been as welcoming as some had hoped.     

Ad Astra **  Sadly I was underwhelmed by this movie.   

Alita: Battle Angel **. Underwhelmed by this one too, but at least it was never trying to be portentous, unlike Ad Astra. 

Captain Marvel *  Brie Larson, Samuel L. Jackson, Jude Law, Annette Bening and  Ben Mendelsohn are all brilliant actors, utterly wasted here.   I have written elsewhere (A Quiet Place) about the potential dangers of people directing their own scripts,  but I would have expected Disney and Marvel to have licked this into shape.   They did not.  

The Lion King   I really enjoyed Jon Fever’s version of The Jungle Book,  but maybe that was because of the performance of the only non-CGI character, Neel Sethi’s Mowgli.   I could find nothing engaging about his seemingly similar venture, despite an equally starry voice cast.   


And on DVD I caught up with: 

Green Book ****  Joker came out of the Hangover stable, which seems to have wrong-footed some critics.   Green Book was directed  by Peter Farrelly of Dumb and Dumber and There’s Something About Mary fame, and written by Brian Currie, who wrote Armageddon and Con Air, so many expectations might also have been up-ended by this offering as it does a thoughtful  and quietly moving account of the true-ish story of the journey made by the famous black pianist Dr. Don Shirley and his driver (and unofficial body-guard)  Tony ‘the Lip’ Vallelonga through the Southern States in the 1950s, with Don playing to white audiences.  But this sensitive and moving film was co-authored by Tony’s son Nick Vallelonga, and the lead actors are Mahershala Ali and Viggo Mortensen, both of whom provide committed performances.  
Best Film of the year?  The Oscars said so, but many disagreed.   I think there were at least three other nominations I would have gone for, but hey, fourth is good. 

The Breadwinner ****  I love the Irish movie Song of the Sea, a Celtic folk tale beautifully animated in the 2 dimensional style of the Book of Kells (see also The Secret of Kells by the same company.)  The Breadwinner comes out of the same stable, but is set in Afghanistan in 2001, where a young girl has to pretend to be a boy in order to support her family when her father is carted off to jail by the Taliban.  The style is very different, the quality and ability to move an audience are the same.    

The Handmaiden ****  Some may have found the violence in Park Chan-Wook’s films Oldboy and Sympathy For Mr Vengeance hard to swallow.   I did.  But I enjoyed Thirst, his take on vampirism and Zola’s novel Therese Raquin,  plus Lady Vengeance and his delightful I’m a Cyborg.    The Handmaiden is his version of Sarah Water’s Victorian lesbian love-story Fingersmith, transplanted by Park to the 1930’s Korea.    This is a complex and very erotic movie, brilliantly staged, filmed and performed.   As it happens it was written by Sen-kyeong Jeong who also co-wrote Lady Vengeance, Thirst and I’m a Cyborg.   

Shadow ***. I usually enjoy Zhang Yimou movies, and really like the historical Hero and The House of Flying Daggers,  as well as his earlier, more conventional, productions set in the 20th century,  such as Red Sorghum,  Qiu Ju and Raise the Red Lantern.   In Shadow he returns to China’s early history and wuxia martial arts, but makes what is for him a unique use of colour.   Always known as a colourist, having initially trained as a cinematographer, in this film he uses black and a million shades of grey, with only the most sparse flesh tones and blood reds.   Narratively complex and visually stunning. 

Annihilation.***  Alex Garland adapted and directed Jeff  Vandermere’s dystopian novel and used Rob Hardy, his cinematographer from Ex Machina,  to shoot it.  His lead players are Natalie Portman, Jennifer Jason-Leigh, Tessa Thompson and Gina Rodriguez, a mixed-skilled team chosen to explore the strange, mysterious and expanding zone, the Shimmer,  that surrounds the site where some kind of alien life-form (crash?) landed and seems to be changing the DNA of all life forms around it.   The movie is as strange and mysterious as the Shimmer itself.   The fact that the team are all women is very welcome.  When they ask ‘Why didn’t you send any men in?’ they are answered ‘We did. None of them came back.’   None except (maybe) Kane (Oscar Isaac),  the Special Ops husband of Lena, the Natalie Portman character.   This was shot in England for Netflix by a very British team, including  Geoff Barrow and Ben Salisbury, who scored Ex Machina.  Some of the male actors are also British, including Benedict Wong, David Gyasi and Josh Danford.   I do not have Netflix (I am afeared of sitting in front of my TV 20/7 if nor 24/7) so I saw this on DVD.    I think I might watch again.   

I know Your Name***(*).  A rather beautiful Japanese anime, concerning two contemporary teenagers who live miles apart but dream of being each other, and set out to find their dream partners.   There are plenty of philosophical twists to this; not all of which I followed on first viewing, but again, I think it deserves  a second. 

The Assassin.***. Korean, gorgeous, somewhat impenetrable.   See below. 

You Were Never Really Here****. Lynne Ramsay and Joaquin Phoenix combine in a brutal yet moving (sort of) thriller.    See below.

Destroyer **** Nicole Kidman on absolutely top form as a broken down cop, and in flashback, her younger self.  See below. 

Thursday, 21 November 2019

The Making of Monsters.


Todd Phillips and Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker. 

‘Whatever does not kill you simply makes you stranger,’  said Heath Ledger’s  Joker in The Dark Knight .    Now we have another and very strange Joker to consider.   

I saw the new movie Joker as soon as it came out and I have been thinking about it ever since.   Meanwhile the movie has taken $1 billion  (£750 million) world wide.   Whatever else it might be Joker is a runaway, record breaking, Box Office success.    It won the Golden Globe at the 2019 Venice film Festival but critically it has proved to be a deeply divisive film. 

I guess that most people who wanted to see this movie have already done so,  and therefor this is not so much a review addressing the question ‘should you go and see it?’  as a response to share with those who have already done so,  a response to some of the questions it raises.    I am, if it is relevant, an ordained minister in the Anglican Church, and trained counsellor and psycho-therapist,  a Child Protection and Safeguarding professional, and of course a film fan and blogger .   I write about movies for my own non-commercial benefit.  Writing helps me think, to seek answers, to ask ‘what does this movie, any movie,  mean to me, and why?’ 

‘Why’ is important, especially when a film such as Joker evokes such visceral responses in so many people.  It has not just been negatively criticised but actually condemned by many.  Some professional critics have said that they ‘hated’ it.    That’s pretty visceral.     

Peter Bradshaw’s judgement in The Guardian is at the less severe end of the critical spectrum.   He simply called it ‘the  year’s biggest disappointment.... solemn but shallow’.    But others  have cut more deeply, some believing that the movie makers did not understand mental illnesses at all, and therefor misrepresented and insulted those who actually suffer from them.    Two British doctors wrote that  ‘Whether intentionally or not, Arthur comes across as a hysterically laughing super-villain, stereotypically “mad” to the untrained eye; a murderous clown laughing alone on a bus.’   (Annabel Driscoll and Mina Husain in The Guardian, 31/10/19).     

At least one senior American Police Officer  feared it would incite ‘copy-cat violence’, promptingWarner Bros  to release a statement pointing out that ‘neither the fictional character Joker, nor the film, is an endorsement of real-world violence of any kind’.       Jeff Yang at CNN  worried that Joker provides ‘an insidious validation of the white-male resentment that helped bring President Donald Trump to power’, and also accused it of racism.   There was also the suggestion that the movie somehow validated not only ‘Trumpism’  but also possible ‘incel’ violence.   Joaquin Phoenix’s performance has been called  showy and self-indulgent.    

So is it shallow, stereotyping, ignorant, dangerous, racist and indulgent? 

I said that Joker’s  effect was sometimes visceral, and it seems that some critics have cast around to find  ‘objective’ justifications for their ‘subjective’ negative gut feelings.     In response to those already mentioned I want to point out that when Arthur is ‘laughing on a bus’  he is neither alone nor yet a killer; he has simply been trying to amuse a child on the crowded bus until the boy’s mother turns on him, triggering the laughter that is Arthur’s stress response.    I also seem to be looking through a different lens to Jess Yang.   I see  Joker as a condemnation of Trumpism rather than an appeal to it.   Nor do I think Yang’s  examples of negative racist portrayals stand up.    The people of colour in the film include Arthur’s Mental Health Worker,  a prison Psychiatrist and an Arkham Asylum clerk, all of whom want to help him, and his single-parent neighbor who - in fact or fantasy - offers him sympathy when his mother is ill.   

On the plus critical side another of the Guardian’s  film critics, Christina Newland,  saw Joker as a cautionary tale showing how  ‘society's ignorance of those who are less fortunate will create a person like the Joker,’ and that  ‘Phoenix is astonishing as a mentally ill geek who becomes the killer-clown Joker’   in a ‘rare comic-book movie that expresses what's happening in the real world.’   

I think this is certainly a film that deserves a second viewing, and when I did go to see it again I paid attention to the soundtrack.   It has often been said that nothing we see on the screen is there by accident, and that is also true of the sound track.    Some of the Joker’s music is an ironic comment on Arthur Fleck’s miserable condition, and some of it is not ironic, but illustrative. 

We start with the jolly Temptation Rag (Claude Bolling), and then Here comes the King, he is second to none  (Steve Karmen),  followed by If You’re Happy and You Know it, Jimmy Durante’sSmile, and the perky Spanish Flea.    The turn comes, perhaps with The Main Ingredient singing  Ok, so your heart is broken, you sit around moping ,cryin’ and cryin’. You say you’re even thinkin’ about dyin’. 
 And then we hear - though not in this precise order; 
I started a joke which started the whole world crying
But I didn't see that the joke was on me oh no
I started to cry which started the whole world laughing
Oh If I'd only seen that the joke was on me.   
(The Bee Gees)

People are strange.  (The Doors.)

I'll wait in this place where the sun never shines
Wait in this place where the shadows run from themselves
(Cream)

Just wait until they hate it
But I ain’t even tripping
I’m pushing when I’m kicking. (Ubansteps)

It’s my life and I’ll do what I want.
It’s my mind and I’ll think what I want. (The Animals)

Worn like a mask of self-hate
Confronts and then dies
Don’t walk away. 
(Joy Division).

You took me by surprise
I didn't realize that you were laughing
'cause you're doin' it to me
(Laughing) it ain't the way it should be
You took away everything I had, you put the hurt on me.
(The Guess Who). 

And if the dam breaks open many years too soon
And if there is no room upon the hill
And if your head explodes with dark forebodings too
I'll see you on the dark side of the moon. 
(Pink Floyd) 

And perhaps most acutely; 
No one knows what it's like
To be the bad man
To be the sad man
Behind blue eyes

I have hours, only lonely
My love is vengeance
That's never free
No one knows what its like
To feel these feelings
Like I do
And I blame you
No one bites back as hard
On their anger
None of my pain and woe
Can show through

No one knows what its like
To be mistreated, to be defeated
Behind blue eyes.   (The Who). 

The film playing on the TV in Arthur’s apartment 1937  Fred Astaire-Ginger Rogers’ “Shall We Dance”.   The musical number playing is called “Slap That Bass” and contains the words “The world is in a mess,  with politics and taxes and people grinding axes, there’s no happiness.”   Arthur dances to it.   He has the gun he has been given in his hand.  He does not know it is loaded until it goes off. 

I think the film is, to a great extent,   a ‘song and dance’ act.   Six, seven or eight times Arthur dances, and each dance expresses something different and pushes the story or the mood onwards. 

The dance critic of The New York Times,  Gia Kourlas, wrote that Joker, ‘seems less a linear tale than a sequence of dances knitted together with dialogue.  In the end, Arthur, though handcuffed, has a song in his head and a spring to his step.  As he disappears down a pristine white hallway, he uses what mobility he has -  his shoulders, which creep up and down to Frank Sinatra’s “That’s Life.”   In any case, the last dance is one of liberation.   As long as he can move, he’s free. And Mr. Phoenix knows how to move. His dancing is no joke.’ 

When Arthur the Clown dances in celebration  on a steep flight of steps to “Rock ’n’ Roll Part 2,”we may remember  how dangerous the persona of Gary Glitter was, and I remind myself that most abusers were themselves abused a children.  That is a thought we might want to push away, but should not.   It is not an excuse for abuse, but it may offer an explanation. 

 I also noticed that the colour scheme of the movie is  purple, barn red,  orange, dirty browns and bluey greens.   This reflects that of The Dark Knight, especially in the scenes involving Heath Ledger’s Joker.    I am  great admirer of The Dark Knight,  (see A Ray of Light in The Dark Knight on my blog) and see Joker as an entirely appropriate companion piece to it.   It is not a ‘prequel’, but  an ‘origins’ story suggesting how someone like the Joker from A Killing Joke and/or The Dark Knight could have become what he was.    

 It is worth recalling that  The Dark Knight’s Joker could not, would not, explain his scars.  He offered two explanations,  both of them terrible, but maybe the truth was even more terrible.  Working as a priest and counselor I learnt that some of those who most need our care and compassion cannot tell us the truth about the causes of their pain, anger or despair.    They cannot bring themselves to say it,  to  remember, to re-member it,  and to describe what actually happened to them.   Victims of abuse are therefor often the least reliable witnesses to their own abuse.    We sometimes think they are lying, making it up.  And sometimes they are.  Their lies are easier for them to share than their truth.  
  
And sometimes (too often)their behavior makes them unappealing.   They can be withdrawn, aggressive, even violent, unpredictable, unreliable,  suspicious and of course utterly ungrateful for any attempts we might make to help them.   How could we possibly help them when we really have no idea what they have suffered?  And they are not going to tell us.   How could they trust us when their trust has already been destroyed.   The worst abuse is always the abuse of trust.    So we never learn how Heath’s Joker got his scars.  

He did, however,  seem to be a figure of disconcerting charisma,  intelligent and sly,  somehow glamorous and  fascinating.  Even his laugh seemed somehow a kind of joie de vivre.   We  might say that there was a kind of tragic, nihilistic heroism about that Joker.   

The Joker in The Dark Knight says he is there to ‘introduce a little anarchy. Upset the established order, and everything becomes chaos. I’m an agent of chaos. Oh, and you know the thing about chaos? It’s fair!’  Nothing that happens to Arthur Fleck is fair.  So why not relish chaos?   

Some critics, its seems,  wanted  Arthur Fleck’s Joker to be heroic, but there is nothing heroic about Arthur.   He may start off  as a sympathetic character, but as the co-writer and Director Todd Phillips has said   “You want to root for this guy until you can’t root for him any longer.”   Arthur fleck does some terrible things.   There are no excuses.    This is not a movie about redemption.   It is about damnation.   It is about the ‘banality of evil.’

Arthur tells his Social Worker, you don’t listen, do you?  I don’t think you ever really listened to me. You just ask the same questions every week. “How’s your job? Are you having any negative thoughts?” All I have are negative thoughts. But you don’t listen. Anyway, I said, for my whole life, I didn’t know if I even really existed. But I do, and people are starting to notice.

And when he does actually get invited onto The Murray Franklin Show Murray asks  Do you have a problem with Thomas Wayne?
Arthur says Yes, I do. Have you seen what it’s like out there, Murray? Do you ever actually leave the studio? Everybody just yells and screams at each other. Nobody’s civil anymore! Nobody thinks what it’s like to be the other guy. You think men like Thomas Wayne ever think what it’s like to be someone like me? To be somebody but themselves? They don’t. They think that we’ll just sit down and take it like good little boys! That we won’t werewolf and go wild!   

At the end, when, far far too late,  he might actually get real help the Arkham Psychiatrist asks: What’s so funny?
Arthur: I was just thinking of a joke.
Psychiatrist: Do you want to tell it to me?
[pause]
Arthur: You wouldn’t get it.

I think some critics didn’t get it either.   For me this is a film about the making of monsters through carelessness.  In Child Protection and Safeguarding circles it is called abusive neglect.    I see this movie showing  what happens when individuals, and the societies we form together,  simply do not care about the most vulnerable in our societies.    We neglect them, and ignore the consequences.   Carelessness can be evil.    Evil and banal. 

Arthur is prone to burst into uncontrollable laughter  at inappropriate moments, particularly when under stress or in pain.    He is often under stress or in pain.  He is on seven kinds of medication.  He is profoundly vulnerable - woundable.  And  he is wounded; stomped on physically in the alleyways and on the Subway,  abused by the neglect of the system that is meant to protect him.  When his mental health worker tells him that the City of Gotham is closing down the support system that provides him with counseling and his prescribed drugs she tells him  ‘Those in charge don’t give a shit about people like you.   And the truth is they don’t give a shit about people like me either.’    Neither the cared for nor the carers.   I see that truth. 

Arthur has tried;  caring for his mother,  clowning in a children’s hospital.  He wants to be a Stand-up Comic,  to get people laughing,  to make them happy.  He dreams (literally dreams) of being on Murray’s late night chat show.    But  ‘madness, as you know, is like gravity.  All it takes is a little push’ said Heath Ledger’s Joker to Batman.   Arthur is pushed and pushed and pushed.   It seems he always has been.     “I haven’t been happy one minute of my entire fucking life,” he tells his mother.  Gradually, and sometimes abruptly, his dreams and hopes have been ground down or dashed.  As well as being abused on the streets, at work and on television, he was, he learns, abused during his unremembered childhood.    I thought my life was a tragedy,  he tells his mother, and maybe he had tried to redeem it, to rescue it, to use it to help others, but now I realize it is a comedy.   
Another clown lent him a gun, ‘for safety’s sake’, but when it drops out of Arthur’s costume while he’s entertaining children in a hospital ward as he sings ‘If You’re Happy and You Know It, ’   Arthur loses his job.   Maybe giving people guns is not the best way to keep them safe.   Maybe ignoring the vulnerable is not the best way to keep them, or any of us,  safe.   
Is this movie  dangerous?   Yes it is, as Keith Mayer said in The Times.   ‘It is profoundly and acutely dangerous in the same way that any film that kicks so conspicuously against orthodoxies is dangerous’.  

As for Phoenix’s  ‘showy and indulgent’ performance, I have to say that at times he moved me to tears, especially when his eyes filled with pain or fear as he laughed or forced a smile.   I might add that losing 52 pounds for a movie role is not ‘indulgent’.    Arthur’s gaunt body is part of the performance of art.   You might compare it with his portrayal of Joe in Lynne Ramsay’s recent ‘You Were Never Really Here’.

I am moved by the movie.    I think it speaks to it’s time, and repeating a warning that so often, too often,  needs repeating.   Back in the early 90’s Josephine Hart was succinct when she wrote  ‘Damaged people damage people,’  in her novel Damage.  If we damage people, or do not look after those who are already damaged, then they (we) are indeed likely to end up damaging other people.    Some  of these victims may even become symbolic figures, or  populist political leaders,  appealing to other damaged, disenfranchised and despairing folk.    Arthur Fleck’s tragic descent into madness and violence is not excused by the  treatment he has received, but it is a reflection on it, and one I think we need to take seriously.    

Chauncey K. Robinson wrote in The People’s World, that this is  ‘ultimately an in-your-face examination of a broken system that creates its own monsters.’    I am not surprised that it has provoked powerful and diverse responses.    

I believe that ‘the least, the last, and the lost’ are - or should - be the true focus of our compassion.    The scriptures tell me  clearly that God is on their side.   So as a counselor, psycho-therapist and priest I think Joker is a truthful, brave, passionate, compassionate and compelling movie,  centred around a performance that maybe only Joaquin Phoenix could craft and deliver.   That is my ‘visceral and thoughtful’ response.    

Thursday, 27 June 2019

Toy Story has 3 gold medals. This is the Victory lap.

I know there was some disquiet about Toy Story 4 even being made.   The BBC and Guardian film critic Mark Kermode was really anxious about it, fearful that the wonderful trilogy was going to be spoilt by an unnecessary addition,  one that was made for the money, ruining his ever-so-valued Toy Story experience.   He now knows that his fears were unfounded.   TS4(or TS Forky as some now call it) is a wonderful victory lap to be enjoyed knowing that the trilogy already has its own Golden medals.  We didn’t know we were waiting for it,  but now that it is here we can rejoice, cheering and waving goodbye.  I am pretty sure it is goodbye. 





It has been 24 years since TS first amazed and moved us.  It was the first ever full length CGI animated movie  and set the bar very high, but ever since then Pixar has pushed that bars  higher and higher both technically and content wise.  Do we remember how amazed we were by the details of the polyester hair on Monsters Inc, or Merida’s flowing hair in Brave, the photo-realist background in WALL-E?    Maybe not, but I can we ever forget the rumbling fears that TS3 fed to us towards the end;  then the triple whammy of  relief followed by the bitter sweet final scene that we thought was the end of TS. 






I will say no more about TS 4 than this.    It is an exciting and sometimes frightening adventure, and it is a love story.   Not just a romantic love story, it goes much deeper than that.    If you want to you can consider its deep existentialist depth - or you simply sit back and enjoy the ride.   If you saw and loved the others I think you will love this one too. If (somehow) you have never seen the others, you could actually start here.    It is not a sequel, it is just a toy story that happens later.  But don’t wait for the DVD;  a movie such as this was made for the Big Beautiful Screen (like Rocketman and BladeRunner 2049), so if you want to see it please go out and make it an event.  

I was prompted by seeing TS4  to write a longer piece about the deep emotional, moral, philosophical and spiritual richness of the movies.    That will be up next folks. 

Tuesday, 25 June 2019

Rocketman is a blast!






At the beginning of Rocketman we see Elton John march into a group therapy session, dressed as a fallen angel in a scarlet red be-winged outfit,  and declare  that he is an alcoholic, a cocaine addict, sex addict, bulimic  - and a shopping addict.    The rest of this  ‘true fantasy’  tells how little Reggie Dwight from Pinner got into this sorry state, and ends, as it starts, with him deciding to battle his way out of it.     It is a terrible story, wonderfully  told, and its postscript tells us that in the end Elton won.  He has of course just been awarded the French Legion d’Honneur to go with his English Knighthood. 

The story is well known,  from his childhood, when it seems his parents tried hard to live up to Philip Larkin’s famous nostrum  -
They fuck you up, your mum and dad.   
    They may not mean to, but they do.   
They fill you with the faults they had
    And add some extra, just for you. 


We follow him through his acceptance at the age of 11 by the Royal College of Music,  meeting Bernie Taupin when he was twenty and breaking into song-writing with him.   That was followed by the fame and fortune that almost  appeared like magic, but were not what he really needed.   It tells of Elton’s  unhappy relationship with John Reid, his one-time lover/manager,  his spiral down into various  addictions and his attempted suicide, all the way to his decision to quit drugs and go into therapy.   The actual chronology is used freely, and in the case of the group therapy invented, but this rearrangement imposes some clarity onto what was really a very chaotic life.   

Most of the songs do not follow the actual chronology of Elton's life and career, and  of course none of them are to his own lyrics, even when they seem to be his personal commentary/confession, but Bernie's lyrics must have been informed by his friend’s  circumstances, and they are used here to fit the  ‘true fantasy’ well. 

Elton was a producer of this movie so I guess he must have put a lot of his money into it and thereby kept it out of the hands of the major studios.   Paying the piper  meant he could have ‘called the tune’ and given him license to whitewash the story  (as in the Queen produced Bohemian Rhapsody).  But Elton once said about being in therapy that "your pride will kill you" and I think this must be the most blisteringly honest bio-pic I have ever seen produced by its protagonist.    The budget also gave artistic freedom and it is, as they say, all up there on the screen.    Much of this story is illuminated by song and dance routines, which are large scale and impressive.    

Dexter Fletcher, who ended up directing Bohemian Rhapsody when Brian Singer was sacked, also directed this, delivering Lee Hall’s script (War Horse, Billy Elliot) and George Richmond’s images (he shot both the Kingsman movies, Tomb Raider and Warhorse) with a sure touch.   Matthew Margeson honours the original music and provides his own unobtrusively, and Taron Edgerton produces an award deserving performance as he sings, dances and plays the adult Elton (Matthew Illesley was nine years old when he played him in childhood).     Jamie Bell plays Taupin, and the guy from Bodyguard, Richard Madden plays Reid (who is painted very black and I suppose it must be true or he would have sued the hell out of them).   

It is good to see so many great  British actors on show, including Gemma Craven,  Stephen Graeme and Stephen Macintosh, alongside the amazing Bryce Dallas Howard as Elton's mother,  who I spent much of the move trying to identify as a Brit, never recognising her American self from Jurassic World – Fallen Kingdom.   



Bryce Dallas Howard

The postscript tells us the good news.   Elton did find someone to love.   Elton and David Furnish married in 2005 and have two adopted children.   Elton has been sober and clean for decades now,  and his AIDs Foundation has raised hundreds of millions of pounds.  He does, however confess to still having a problem with shopping.  I guess he can afford it. 

So,  although having doubts about the depiction of the therapy group, which might give some people a false impression of how they actually work, I think Rocketmanis a really good movie, telling an important story that has a clear message for all those who aspire for fame and fortune - and about the absolute need for forgiveness.     None of it would work, however, without the brilliance of the music, and I was very pleased to see it made clear that it is Taupin who has always written the brilliant and essential  lyrics for Elton to put to music,  and that Bernie retained his sanity while Elton was going crazy.  Their friendship is also a true love story, if never a romanic one..     

I saw Rocketman on a very big screen with a good sound system and if you can get to a proper cinema screen it is really worth the effort, this is a Big Movie, with Big Music - and a Big Story to tell.